The Sims 4 – the good, the bad and the ugly

The Sims 4. Not a game I was really looking forward to. That alone made me a little sad. I’ve bought all The Sims games since the very first one, nearly all the EPs and SPs and a ton of store content for TS3. And on the whole I’ve enjoyed them all. But nothing looked particularly great about TS4. The screenshots looked cartoony and all EA seemed to push were the Sims and their emotions, something I really couldn’t give a damn about. They sacrificed toddlers, again something I couldn’t care about but I can see how story tellers and legacy players would be annoyed. The lack of swimming pools is a bit disappointing but I can live with that.

The following is a compilation of all the stuff I’ve come across over the last couple of days that’s made an impression, be it good, bad or ugly.

The good:

  • The game loads in seconds and the loading screens are quick when you’re travelling around town (for now at least, before DLC and EPs no doubt slow it down).
  • It feels so smooth to play. No juddering or lag (so far…).
  •  CAS and build mode seem a lot easier for those who just want to get on and play the game. I have no interest in CAS so for me, taking 5 minutes to make a semi decent Sim was a bonus.
  • The roofing tool has been given a proper upgrade. You can have different patterned and coloured roofing sections. You can also quickly make the roof convex or concave by pulling up or down on the little white ball that appears when you select the roof section.
  • I love, love, LOVE being able to make objects bigger. This really makes landscaping a lot better as the selection of outdoor plants and rocks isn’t exactly large. In build mode you bring up the cheat console, type in testingcheats true and hit enter. Then grab an object, let go of the mouse, hold down Shift and press ]. To make the object smaller again hold down Shift and press [. As soon as you move the object you’ll see the size difference:


The bad:

  • There is no CASt. I’m finding it really hard to love this game for the simple reason that EA decided to take out CASt, something which we are so used to that it really seems like a massive step backwards. And most of EA’s colours and patterns are downright hideous. I swore that I wouldn’t buy TS4 because there was no CASt and now that I have I knew I should have trusted my instincts. It’s very hard to make a really great room or to have a standard theme running through a build because there’s no way to mix and match colours and patterns properly.
  • There is no MOO. Another thing that we’ve become so accustomed to and enjoyed using. You can slightly overlap some objects but this sometimes results in the objects disappearing. My Sim’s front door was constantly vanishing until I moved a flower pot which was nearby.
  • Not having the same camera control interface or possibilities, especially in build/buy mode.
  • The edges of bookcases and other objects placed in a corner still disappear slightly into the wall. This has always really annoyed me in TS3. It looks like one edge of a bookcase is missing.
  • When you’re in build/buy mode the controls are all over the place. The catalogue items are at the bottom, like they’ve always been. The eyedropper, grab and similar tools are along the top of the screen. The options, save, gallery and similar are in the top right of the screen.

The ugly:

  • No OS X version and no word from EA if there will ever be one. They’ve obviously learnt from their massive mistake using Cider for TS3 but why no native version for OS X? getting ready for the usual, pointless ‘Macs aren’t gaming machines’ comments from the less informed
  • Whilst the graphics are softer than TS3 I can’t help thinking that The Sims 4 looks like a Facebook version of The Sims 2 on acid.
  • The loading screens. Yes, they load quickly but my god they are annoying. You can’t just have a nosy around the neighbourhood whilst your Sim’s doing their thing because there isn’t really anywhere to look around. If you want to look around another area, for example where the library is, you have to send your Sim there so you can have a look. It’s such a giant step backwards and it ruins the flow of gameplay considerably.
  • Not being able to place empty lots in the neighbourhood and no really small lots. 20×15 is the smallest lot size.
  • I keep getting an annoying glitch whereby when I click on a house to edit, or a sim to play, I get the plumbob loading screen then it goes back to the town view. No matter what lot I try to enter this happens. The only solution is to quit the game and reload it.

Other stuff:

The fridges not snapping to counters really irks me:


But the way the counters snap to each other is seamless, especially round open corners. I also like the way the splashbacks only appear when the counters are up against the wall :

It’s quite ironic that a game I have spent the last 5 years complaining about, The Sims 3, is the game I’m going back to isn’t it? A game that always feels like it’s going to kill my Mac any minute and limps along like a lame puppy. But despite all the problems with TS3, which are infinite, the overall gameplay and creative possibilities are great. The Sims 4 just feels empty, like there’s something missing but I can’t precisely pinpoint what it is.


3 thoughts on “The Sims 4 – the good, the bad and the ugly

  1. I feel like you I am not sure, I like it, but not sure I don’t like it. It has no real gameplay for me that sims 2 doesn’t have, it is just easier to make the sims & build. I am hoping with EP’s the gameplay will improve. I could not believe they have already patched it twice. I was gifted the game by a dear friend or I do not think I would have it right now. I would have waited for a sale and at least one expansion. One thing I find that I can do is, I can play the family and then just exit out without saving as I am not as attached to my sims as I was previously, I am just not that interested in the game play. It is more for the casual gamer, not the story teller or the legacy people. I hope I grow to enjoy it. Since we paid so much for the game it should run well, but I have bugs with my shower not turning off and I had one crash to the desktop and my computer is overkill for the specs. I was really hoping the game would at least run and run exceedingly well since they took so much out of it, but, that was a wish that was not fulfilled. ;-( Not sure I am going any further with this game, but who knows I could change my mind, still hoping for a better game.


  2. i absolutely agree with you 100% of all the things you’ve listed here! I’ve been playing ts4 in bootcamp and it keep crashing every half an hour! The game is great, I really do enjoy it and the game as evolved so much since ts1. But it would make things easier if they just made ts4 on mac!!

    it sucks features like you building a pool and other things arn’t there! I guess we will have to wait until the expansion packs come out and see what other features they have! i do love the building mode now, all the designs are modern and the actual controlling and gameplay is much easier!


Leave a reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.